As some of you may already know, Lizzie has become a Bollywood nut. Most nights when I’m here at my desk diligently cobbling shoes, she’s watching some other silly romantic pap imported at great cost from overseas. Tonight, though, she convinced me (while a big download processed) to start watching the one she had read about and gotten from the Skokie Library: Rang De Basanti.
Now, if I’m going to watch movies about India, I’m less about Bollywood* and more about historical films like Gandhi. This one kind of meets in the middle. It’s about a British film maker who goes to India to film a dramatic documentary about Bhagat Singh, someone I hadn’t heard of until tonight. Completely convinced it was all made up, I consulted with the Wikipedia Gods who have treated Doug, among others, so well, and found out that he was fairly accurately portrayed in this movie. If you believe those lying bastards.
I wouldn’t call this Bollywood. I’d call it a Hindi film (and Lizzie, the expert, agrees). There are a couple of musical numbers, but mostly it’s a very good story. In fact, it’s so good that the three hours it spans felt like only two and a half. You might not think this is a glowing review, but most three-hour Bollywood movies feel to me like five hours. So there you go. It’s quite tragic in spots, and (without giving up a spoiler) has a very predictable plot twist that normally would be silly but feeds the rest of the film very well. In other words, when you feel the need to roll your eyes, stick with it — the twist actually matters.
The problem is the length. I recommend it to everyone, of course, but more than three hours of anything can be hard to take. I suggest you give it a shot, though. The acting is totally different from Bollywood standards, and the story is compelling and nicely merged with the historical context of Bhagat Singh. And there’s a little epilogue screen about the corruption in Indian government at the end that kind of validates the whole shebang. Moreover, the acting is just better (from a western perspective) — you really do start to care about these people after a while, as opposed to the usual Bollywood reaction of wondering why the men twitch so much when they’re upset.
Lizzie will be the first to tell you that I pretty much hate movies. In my opinion they are manipulative and silly, and rarely provide enough payback for the time spent watching them. This one is pretty good, though.
* I love a good Bollywood romp now and then, but I can’t typically sit through a whole movie. Lizzie likes the dramas, as they tend to have more plot and can carry you through. I like the dumb ones like Jis Desh Mein Ganga Rehta Hain, starring the charming Govinda and having deliciously extravagant dance numbers in rural India mixed with dumb slapstick comedy and a melodramatic plot. Sadly, my tastes don’t translate well to marathon three-hour movies. At least if you’re an impatient westerner like me.